Rail Freight Audit

Railroads bill demurrage, storage and dozens of accessorial charges under their own published rules. Those rules change often, and the bills don't always follow them. We check every charge against the rule that was in force on the day it happened and give you the disputes, ready to file.

Free audit of one month's demurrage invoice

Send us one month of demurrage charges from BNSF, CSX, Norfolk Southern, Union Pacific, CN or CPKC. We'll check every car against the railroad's published rules and send back a report of what doesn't match, with the dispute text written for you. No cost, no obligation.

Request your free audit

How it works

  1. You export your invoices. Download the demurrage statement and the car event detail from your railroad's customer site (ShipCSX, AccessNS, BNSF's customer tools, UP's customer site, CN eBusiness or CPKC Customer Station), plus any accessorial invoices you want checked. We never ask for your railroad login.
  2. We check every charge. Each car and each invoice line is compared with the railroad's rules in force on that date: rates, credits and free time, allowances owed when the railroad caused the delay, charges billed before they took effect, and charges that aren't in the tariff at all.
  3. You get a report and the dispute text. Every item shows the rule, the event times that support it and the dollars. Items where the railroad's own rules are unclear or contradict each other are listed separately, so you can see which money is settled and which is an argument.
  4. You file before the deadline. Each railroad sets its own dispute window, some as short as about 15 days, and we put the deadline at the top of the report. Railroads require the bill to be paid on terms, so the dispute asks for a credit.

What we check

Demurrage and storage

When the clock started and stopped, credits and free time, holidays, bad-order days, the right rate for the car type and date, and private cars on your own track.

Railroad-caused delays

Missed switches, late empties and late placement notices that the railroad's rules excuse or credit, but that still show up on the bill.

Accessorial charges

Diversions, shipping-instruction fees, car orders not used, weighing, overloads, switching, unit train charges and cleaning, checked for rate, unit, caps and duplicates.

Rate changes

Railroads revise their charge books several times a year. We check each charge against the version in force on the event date.

Background: rail demurrage fees guide. To estimate charges on a single scenario, try the demurrage calculator.

Other rail bills we review

  • Railcar repair invoices — billing repair cards checked against the car, the industry price list and owner vs handling-line responsibility. See railcar repair billing explained.
  • Freight bills — line-haul against your price authority or tariff, fuel surcharge against the published program for the right month, and duplicate billing. See your rail freight invoice, explained.
  • Railcar property tax — state assessments checked against actual in-state mileage, valuations and idle time. See the railcar property tax guide.
  • Lease charges and credits — return-condition charges, re-billed repairs and mileage allowance you are owed. See railcar mileage allowance.

Who this is for

  • Shippers paying demurrage or storage every month without anyone reviewing it
  • Lessees on net railcar leases receiving repair invoices and tax bills
  • Companies whose rail invoices are approved by accounts payable, not someone who knows rail
  • Shippers who want an outside check before renegotiating rates or leases

Billing review is also part of our outsourced rail department for shippers who want the whole rail function handled.

Frequently Asked Questions

Do you need access to our railroad account?

No. You download the files and send them to us. We use them only for your audit.

Which railroads do you cover?

BNSF, CSX, Norfolk Southern, Union Pacific, CN and CPKC: all six Class I railroads.

What if the railroad says no?

Most billing errors are corrected through the railroad's own dispute process and your account manager. For regulated traffic, the Surface Transportation Board's Rail Customer and Public Assistance office and its arbitration program are further options. We'll tell you which options apply to your shipments.

What does it cost?

The first month's demurrage audit is free. After that, pricing depends on your volume and the railroads involved. We'll talk it through with you.

How long do I have to dispute a railcar repair invoice?

Under the current industry billing manual, an unpaid repair invoice has to be returned within 60 days, and a paid one can be challenged within 7 months, or 10 months for leased equipment. Your lease may set a shorter clock for charges re-billed to you.

Do you need to change railroads or contracts to use this?

No. We review what you are already being billed under your current railroads, leases and tariffs.

Who does the work?

Steel Wheel Logistics. Our team has over 25 years of experience in rail operations.

Request your free audit

We'll email you instructions for sending the invoice files. We use them only for your audit.

Paying Demurrage Nobody Checks?

Send us one month's demurrage invoice. We'll check every car and send back what doesn't match, with the dispute text written.

Request your free audit Book a 30-Minute Call